Nobody Knows Where Native Plants Were and That's Okay
One of the biggest tensions in the native plant movement is figuring out what is actually native to your yard. Some people take it very seriously. Some are completely confused by the whole thing. Both reactions make sense once you dig into the problem.
The accepted definition of a native plant is one that was growing before European settlement of North America without direct or indirect human introduction. Simple enough. Except it immediately runs into the indigenous peoples problem. Native people managed the land with fire for thousands of years and moved plants they relied on to areas where they needed them. We generally set that aside because we are talking about introductions from other continents, but it is worth acknowledging that the landscape Europeans encountered was already a managed one.
That definition also raises a harder question that almost nobody asks out loud: how do we know where a plant was growing before 1500? The honest answer is we don't. Not really. So how are we supposed to figure out what to plant?
The Race Botany Lost
European colonization was probably the largest and fastest land transformation in recorded human history. Europe had been largely cleared for centuries. When colonists got here they found enormous stands of old growth timber and millions of acres of prairie sitting on the richest soil anyone had ever seen. People flooded in, moved west, and started cutting. Wetlands were considered useless and they started draining those too. By 1850 the stage was set for the final push. In the next fifty or sixty years, less than one percent of the original prairies survived. Most of the forests and the vast majority of wetlands were functionally gone.
So where were the botanists during all of this? Early on, you could count them on one hand. Before 1850 they were mostly moving along waterways and trade routes, not scouring millions of square miles of interior landscape. They were collecting specimens to send back to England and trying to describe and name new species as fast as they could. Taxonomy was barely organized. The international naming standard was not even created until 1753. North America was barely documented at all.
Through the 1800s things moved faster. Botanists could get to more places and herbarium collections grew. But the location data is often comically vague. "Near a river." "Illinois." "Found from Virginia to Georgia." The plants were still being formally named into the 1920s. The whole thing was a race and botany did not win it.
The short version: we have a reasonably solid grasp of what plants are native to North America. We have a much looser sense of where they were. The Eastern Temperate Forest alone covers roughly one to 1.2 million square miles of land. It is one of the largest and most complex temperate forest systems on earth. It was never fully surveyed in a pre-disturbance state, and it never will be. If you want to go deeper on the timeline of what was lost before botanists could document it, Do We Actually Know a Plant's Native Range? covers that in detail.
The BONAP Problem Nobody Talks About
If you have spent any time in native plant circles you have heard people cite BONAP county maps like they are gospel. Plant X is native to your county, plant Y is not, end of discussion. The problem is that is not what BONAP is or what it was designed to do.
BONAP has a limitations page. Almost nobody reads it. It states clearly that county level maps are not an accurate representation of native plant distributions. Some species are not even reliable at the state level. BONAP is a database of collected herbarium specimens with location data attached. It shows you where plants have been found and recorded. It does not show you where plants were growing before 1850. Those are two very different things, and conflating them is a mistake that native plant purists make constantly while BONAP quietly lets them get away with it.
Do not take my word for it. BONAP says it themselves on their limitations page. They know but for some reason felt it was better not to tell anyone.
Disappointing to some will be our assessment of nativity, which applies geographically only to the level of state, province or equivalent. Those who understand the difficulty in determining nativity, even at the state level, will realize that finer determination is impractical and imprecise.
Think about what we just covered. Around 80 percent of the herbarium specimens in existence were collected after 1900. By then the landscape had already been massively transformed. We are largely mapping where plants survived or naturalized after the fact, not where they were thriving in intact pre-settlement communities. Using county lines drawn for political and administrative purposes to define ecological nativity is a category error. Counties are not ecosystems.
So What Do We Actually Do With This
This is where it starts to sound hopeless, and it is not. The EPA did something genuinely useful. They mapped and created ecoregions, a national framework that divides the country into ecological regions based on shared environmental characteristics: soil parent material, hydrology, climate, and vegetation patterns. When you overlay the plant specimen records we do have against ecoregion boundaries instead of county lines, you get a much more ecologically meaningful picture of plant distributions. Not perfect. Good enough to make decisions with.
The only ecoregion-based plant mapping tool I know of that is actually built for this purpose is bplant.org. Alex built it as a genuine alternative to county maps, pulling from multiple record sources to create something more useful for real restoration decisions. It is not infallible. You still need critical thinking and site-specific research. But at least you are working from an ecologically grounded framework instead of a human boundary map that was never intended for this use.
You also need to account for current conditions. Your yard may sit in an ecoregion that was historically mesic forest, but if your soil is construction fill with a thin layer of topsoil on it, that historical context only goes so far. The landscape is vastly different than it was and the species we are trying to support have to live in that landscape now, not the one from 1700.
There is also a deeper question hiding in all of this that the purist crowd tends to avoid. Why would we try to recreate a museum of ecosystems that no longer exist in a landscape that no longer supports them? A wood thrush needs hundreds of acres of unbroken mature forest. Your yard cannot provide that no matter what you plant. A monarch needs open corridors of milkweed and nectar sources across a landscape, not a shaded woodland garden. The point is not that trees are wrong or that any one plant is wrong. The point is that historical accuracy is not the same thing as ecological usefulness. Plant for your ecoregion, your actual site conditions, and the wildlife that can realistically use what you are building.
The Bottom Line
There is no perfect answer here. The data was never complete, the landscape changed before anyone could document it, and the arguments over county lines are built on a foundation that was never as solid as people pretend. What we can do is use the best available framework, which is ecoregions, layer in real site conditions, focus on wildlife value, and stop pretending that a BONAP county record is proof of anything beyond where someone found a plant after most of the original ecosystems were already gone.
Use ecoregions. Stop arguing over county lines. The plants do not care about the boundaries we drew.